Shakedowns
July 4th, 2009A reader asks why I haven’t written about the so-called shakedown arrests scandal that is scaring everyone away from Thailand. I assume he is referring to the highly publicized Phuket incident involving an Australian woman, and the 3 farang men who where arrested for drug possession just outside Pattaya.
I haven’t written about these specific cases, because no matter what position I take, a hostile rebuttal is sure to follow. It’s all being played out on the forums and I see no reason to invite it over here. So I’ll go ahead and talk about it in general terms, but I’m not going to comment on any specific incidents, nor will I permit anyone else to.
Thailand has a system in place. Similar systems exist in other areas of the world, but are usually not found in countries most would define as having a mature democratic society. The system applies to everyone, NOT just visitors.
When a person breaks the law he/she usually, but not always, has the option of making restitution without enduring the rather lengthy and more costly formal process. For minor violations, the cost of informal restitution is rather well defined. For more serious infractions, the accused will be informed as to what is considered appropriate, but may also be asked to leave the Kingdom. Anyone wishing to exercise their right to a more formal process is welcome to do so, but in Thailand you do not have the right to a speedy conclusion, nor should one be anticipated. Thus, it can get very expensive.
There are those that believe accusations are often manufactured. I have no doubt a small percentage are, BUT more likely than not it was preceded by highly inappropriate conduct on the part of the accused. You are a guest in this country, and don’t forget it. The attitude, shared by more than a few, that spending money here automatically guarantees them the right to behave like arrogant jerks is most definitely flawed.
These are beautiful, kind, and exceedingly friendly people, but treat them as second class citizens and you may very well find yourself on the wrong side of misery. And when approached by an individual in a position of authority you would be wise to all but kiss his ass. Showing ANY disrespect to a uniformed officer is just begging for a very unpleasant stay in the Land of Smiles.
A couple of years ago I was approached by an officer in a public park and firmly told to put my cigarette out. At that time I didn’t know it was illegal to smoke in a public park. I immediately complied with his demand and told him I was sorry. I did not receive a ticket, and was not asked to make informal restitution. A friend had a similar experience. The only difference with him was the cop then bummed a cigarette.
Don’t put too much stake in the spin people give these isolated incidents that go public. All too often there is more to the story than meets the eye. I truly believe that people who find themselves in these situations went asking for it. For those that want to break the law, enjoy behaving like an animal, are a mean and/or obnoxious drunk, or have issues with authority figures, I strongly suggest you either bring lots of extra money or stay home.
This is a VERY sensitive subject, so those wishing to comment should choose their words carefully or I’ll delete them.
For you Americans out there - Happy 4th of July!












